"American Experience" New York Underground (TV Episode 1997) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Building of the New York Subway system makes fascinating story...
Doylenf8 February 2008
Fascinating documentary on the construction of the N.Y. subway which opened in 1903. Includes the various accidents that made improvements necessary, the switch from steam engines to electric tracks, the stories that made newspaper headlines throughout the early part of the 1900s, and newsreel footage of various stages of progress that led to the ultimate underground system we have today. The latter footage is extremely interesting for history buffs who enjoy seeing how New York City looked when the railroad was being constructed.

The program that followed on PBS showed how Grand Central Station was constructed and made an excellent companion piece to the "New York Underground" segment. Once again, the footage showing what 42nd street looked like during that era made for a fascinating glimpse of history in progress.

These "American Experience" shows are in a class by themselves.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Once More Into The Suburbs,.
rmax30482318 November 2017
New York City boomed after the Civil War. People came from all over, from other continents, and two million of them squeezed into a sliver of an island eleven miles long, mostly on its lower half. The result was an enormous traffic jam that impeded any kind of travel.

Horse-drawn trolleys moved at about three miles per hour with frequent interruptions from horse-drawn carriages. A healthy horse left ten pounds of manure daily on the cobblestone streets. There were no street lights so vehicles banged into one another. The streets and sidewalks were also jammed with pedestrians. A blizzard in 1888 shut New York City down completely. It was "Bedlam", as one writer put it.

One of the first proposals, by an inventor named Alfred Beach, was to build a pneumatic subway under Broadway with a giant fan at the end. It would suck cars on rails one way or the other by creating vacuums. The British had already built an underground in London, basically a railroad with the locomotive driven by steam and it seemed more practical except that passengers couldn't tolerate the exhaust and cinders. Beach began building his vacuum tube under Broadway at night to escape the notice of Boss Tweed, the corrupt moneybags who ran the city.

Beach's 1878 tunnel was only a few blocks long but it was a splendid demonstration of his goal. The car was upholstered and lighted with chandeliers, a vast improvement over anything available above them. There were goldfish swimming in the fountains at each end of the tunnel. When it became public, the project was vetoed (twice) by Boss Tweed. In any case a pneumatic subway could only manage one car and then only for a short distance. The tunnel was reduced first to a shooting gallery and then sealed.

In the 1890s, with a reform mayor in charge, a financier named August Belmont organized funding for the building of a tunnel that ran from City Hall to Grand Central Station, then splitting into two branches and heading north under the river to the Bronx. Building a tunnel under the Harlem River was demanding of the chief engineer, William Barclay Parsons, and of the men. It was dangerous work using steel pipes. A brilliant engineer, Parsons was sent abroad to study the technology used in Europe -- London already had its Underground and Paris its Metro. Germany was starting to build one, the Stadtbahn. There, Parsons saw electric trains at work. Electricity was a marvel at the time and was replacing other forms of energy in cities.

In 1900 Parsons broke ground for the subway in New York, widely celebrated with church bells, ship's whistles, and fireworks. It was named the Interborough Rapid Transit system, or IRT. It annoyed the hell out of New Yorkers during construction. Everything seemed to be torn up and one lady on elegant Fifth Avenue complained that she could hear the vulgar language used by the workers.

Most of the workers were immigrants. The most dangerous positions were tunnel workers ("sandhogs") who were paid $6 per day. Several were killed. As construction expanded to Brooklyn, dozens more died. One guy's survival sounds like a miracle. He was working in a compressed air cylinder deep beneath the East River when the overhead failed and blew out. Ceegan was sucked up into the hole, blown through the mud and sand of the East River, and regained consciousness floating on the water.

It was finally opened in October, 1904, attended by great pomp. The financier Belmot had his private entrance and opulent private car. Each stop was not only functional but artistically decorated. The subway was jammed and relieved street traffic but as often happens there was a great demand for more miles of track, which brought the city to what had been farm land. Edgar Allen Poe had lived in a little rural cottage in the Bronx in the early 1800s. By 1907 he wouldn't have recognized it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed