Trigger warning: rape mentioned.
I can only assume people rating it high are only just interacting with these histories or are Americans because there were loads of things in these documentaries that were completely out of context or they honed in on something small and exaggerated a lot. At one point in the first episode a contributor said that Gadaffi was the most prolific rapist in history and this is really not true. Not when people like Ghengis Khan existed. They should have condemned his actions without telling a straight lie. None of the contributors did were necessary voices or authorities on the subjects, definitely not enough to speak in such absolutions. There were times when they got Americans to speak about situations when they were not legitimate contributors to any point e.g. Finding the wife of someone who died on a plane to talk about the impact when the plane crashed instead of the people who were in the town and lost half their community. Considering that this community still exists and you can literally walk in and ask folks questions I found it bizarre that to measure impact they found someone who's husband was an innocent bystander instead of in the direct firing line. They then framed it that this was an attack on the US when the plane crashed in Scotland and people from 19 nations died in the attack. Either they had a really low budget and couldn't interview someone in Scotland or they're using these facts to fuel nationalism, it's a really weird documentary.
Just in general it was really poor documentarian practice. And this was a string of docuseries I'm watching for research and its definitely the worst out of all of them I'm watching. Please do not take the facts in this series as law, do some more reading, Google the claims (especially when contributors seem to ridicule something, these tend to be the moments where some context has been removed) and keep interacting with history documentaries. I promise there are good ones!
6 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink