After moving into a new town, Molly encounters Scratch who decides to put a curse on Molly for entering his home to try and get the McGee family to flee.
Molly attends a camping trip to answer the most important question of her life: Who will her best friend be? Scratch teaches Molly's softball team what it feels like to win.
Molly raises money to rebuild the old Brighton Bandshell and bring the town together. Molly and Scratch try to find a band to headline Brighton's first bandshell concert.
When the McGees are tight on cash, Mom turns to an app called Gig-Pig. Molly learns mo' money means mo' problems when she and Andrea team up to make a scary movie.
When Scratch tells Molly he can get Abe Lincoln to help with her project, he scrambles to cover his lie. When Mom and Grandma Nin aren't getting along, Molly makes them make up.
Molly tries to throw Libby the best Bat Mitzvah ever, but misses the mark. When Darryl gets in trouble at school, Molly volunteers to help reform his ways.
Pete and Molly put a Turnip Fest to win Best Fest of the mid-west over Brighton's rival town: Perfektborg. For one day, Molly can only say "yes" and Scratch can only say "no".
When Molly meets Brighton's legendary founder, she realizes he's not the hero history made him out to be. Molly tries to prevent Libby from humiliating herself in the school talent show without shattering her newfound confidence.
When constantly lying to Libby about Scratch begins to take a toll, Molly struggles to keep Scratch a secret. When Libby and Scratch struggle to be friends with each other, Molly sends them on a scavenger hunt.
When a blackout occurs on the last night of Hanukkah, the people of Brighton seek refuge in Libby's mom's bookstore. Molly tries to convince Andrea's father to save Christmas after budget cuts leave Brighton without its Snowflake Festival.