"Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" Did You Believe in Miracles? (TV Episode 2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
On His Way Out the Door Departing Producer Shades Stabler
This was a solid SVU episode about a culty church and an enigmatic groomer -- but it will forever be remembered as a giant middle finger to Chris Meloni/Elliot Stabler.

As millions of SVU fans saw on social media in April of 2022 during shoots in NY for this episode, Mariska Hargitay and Chris Meloni filmed a sweet Mother's Day scene (the characters bump into each other on the street) during which Benson finally introduces her son Noah to her former partner -- something Stabler has been lobbying for for months.

The scene was all over social media for weeks and further hyped because this episode was part of an OC crossover that kicked off during this very street scene.

When Benson learns a child has been abducted and she happens to be the daughter of a dirty cop in OC's 'Brotherhood,' she tells Stabler she'll fill him in by phone as she races off to drop Noah back at home.

With five minutes still to go on the SVU 9-10 p.m. Clock, Dick Wolf then slides OC's Danielle Mone Truitt as Bell and Ainsley Siegers as Jet into the picture, creating a seamless transition between the two shows.

Just one problem: Meloni's scene was cut from the versions of the show delivered to Hulu, Peacock and other streaming services, and was also cut from broadcasts in Canada and beyond. So in this version the show concludes with Benson and Noah at Mother's Day lunch.

The street scene was apparently regarded as not really meaningful by the exiting producer, which is not only inaccurate but ludicrous. It cheated fans of continuity and of one of the more engaging moments of the season -- and blew the pivotal OC set-up.

The company line was that the two TV show hours had to be delivered as separate shows to the streamers. OK makes sense, but why cut anything? It's streaming! No show has to come in at an exact running time.

And in particular why cut Stabler meeting the kid, and Liv learning of this emergency?

Just pick it up with Jet and Bell doing their thing. OR start OC with Benson and Stabler meeting on the street learning of what then becomes an intersquad case. Or leave some version of it in both shows.

Wolf has already squandered an entire year with all kinds of continuity issues on the Benson Stabler front. Is it really that hard to let two characters who have known each other nearly 25 years, have one actual conversation, and maybe then figure out what if anything they mean to each other?

Nobody wants a garbage will-they-wont-they. Just let a couple of adults be adults. Maybe SVU's new producer will grasp this.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
.
artemisgabor8 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Yes the plotline is frustrating but it's based on a real life case that happened in the early 70s. And yes the real life case is also very frustrating (instead of God's will brainwashing, the guy apparently used 'you're special. You're an alien and if you tell anyone they will vaporize.) She was kidnapped a second time by him after the parents once again let him into their lives but two years later.

How can parents be so naive even in early 70s pre-serial killer phenomena and pre- pedophilia being a well known thing, even if they are in a closed off Mormon community?

So sometimes life is weirder than fiction.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Cult Like Thing
shelbythuylinh6 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
As a girl that seemed to be brainwashed by a man that claims to be "Godly" also happens to have a thing for the girl's mother. Poor girl being brainwashed there.

How that the parents of the girl trusted that so called "friend" as the "mission trip" is just a hoax. To lure the girl to him.

If that is not sickening do not know what is. Olivia gets also a great Mother's Day surprise but duty calls and leads to OC!
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
God's Plan
yazguloner14 May 2022
There's a good enough mystery story to find the missing girl. The narration of the predator's abuse of the family is well conveyed.

Squad is a full Svu section with text and plot. Well explained.

Khalid's charismatic character could be in Svu squad.

Just, the relationship between the family man and the predator could have been the final shock of another story.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Abducted in Plain Sight
lottiemurphy737 May 2022
This episode is based on the documentary Abducted in plain sight , I think . A lot of similarities between this episode and the Netflix documentary . Although religion isn't a basis of the documentary .
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Abducted in Plain sight
tommieadamsphoto30 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I really enjoyed this episode. I always enjoy when the entire SVU squad is involved in a case. Over the years your start to see how it is important for great team when they operate as a family because they know each other so well - which plays into a scene with Captain Benson and Det Rollins.

That aside -- it was a fairly solid episode where a religious zealot grooms and kidnaps a young girl as part of a vision from God. As the story unfolds you see how the predator has manipulated both victim and family using religion as the weapon to build trust.

There were a couple scenes and rhetoric that hit home and ripped from my own headlines being raised in the church and seeing how predators use religion and rhetoric to groom and use a congregation.

Great episode. Give it a watch.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This episode did not depict Christianity
gailhrussell7 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Sometimes the depiction of God goes off the rails and that is what happened here. I believe stuff like this is created to be able to say, "you see, those religious Wack Jobs are nuts". True Christians are not religious, they love Jesus Christ and what He did for the world by dying on the cross for their sins. That is loving, not being religious. I gave this episode a ten because of story line and I just love SVU.
10 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Please stop the Church-hate
dusadomovine8 May 2022
Please find other settings for these sorts of stories. The number of times Christians are used as the setting for these sort of stories is becoming disturbing because it seems like it has an agenda of creating hate against Christians. Why are other religious groups (if ever) used as a setting? Once again, demeaning Christians and creating this sort of animosity which leads to hate is not acceptable.
13 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Episode 20
bobcobb30124 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Nothing that special or that upsetting about the story tonight, but it just felt like something we've seen 100 times. The Noah stuff is starting to get annoying though.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot
garysteinweg12 May 2022
This started out a complex missing female teenager story (complex because of the "cork-screwed" parents), but started becoming a more complex story as to who's done what to who.

Near the end of the episode, it became obvious that this was going to be a two-parter, presumably finished up in "Organized Crime" which followed at 10pm. The transition consisted of Benson calling a halt to going with her son to get ice cream so she could all of a sudden follow-up on something else (not clear exactly what).

So, watching "Organized Crime" next for the wrap-up of this brassiere story was a REAL letdown as it wasn't connected at all to the preceding SVU teenager story. WTF.

It has to be a failure on my part to interpret what's going on.

UPDATE: Welp, I just finished watching the next episode (5/12) of SVU. There was NO follow-up or reference to this episode. So, this episode simply went of a cliff. Unresolved and ignored. Consequently, I'm going to downgrade my rating.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dumb & Dumber
byablue4 August 2022
Writers' Meeting: "Let's have an episode about the biggest airhead parents on the planet."

Every time the mother opened her mouth, I wanted to smack her. This review won't be accepted unless I use at least 150 words. I can't think of 150 words to express the level of dumbness in this episode. Idiotic, moronic, asinine, stupid, ditzy, dim-witted, obtuse, dense. Okay that's enough.

Bleh. 1 star because zero is not an option.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Ugh, What an Offensive Episode
bkkaz6 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Hoo, boy, the Law and Order franchise has always had a weird time with Asian characters. If they're not fresh off the boat stereotypes -- prostitutes, dry cleaners, convenience store clerks -- they're gang bangers or Yakuza. Never just regular every day Americans. You know, like everyone else.

They've especially had a hard time with Asian males. Now, think carefully. When have you seen an Asian male who wasn't a stereotype? When have they ever been given the same place in the masculine hierarchy as the other males? When's the last strong, virile Asian male you've seen in any of the Law and Order shows?

BD Wong, you say. Yes, BD Wong turns up because he's pretty much the only Asian male any of the Law and Order shows have had as a regular (or semi-regular, depending on how you look at it). Only, he was largely bookish. But of course he would be an academic overachiever. And of course he would be physically helpless. In one episode, he's beaten unconscious and Stabler has to rescue him. Olivia Benson and all the ADAs stood a head taller than him.

And he was gay. There's absolutely nothing wrong with an LGBTQ Asian character. But given that the majority of Asian men aren't statistically members of the LGBTQ community, wouldn't it seem reasonable that at least one -- one -- straight Asian male regular would be in the franchise? I mean, just one?

I say this because tonight we have a multiple rarity -- not only an Asian male, but one married to a White female. Wow, that's a combination you almost never see in American television. Only, he's cuckolded by his wife (who cheats on him with, of course, a White male). Because, you know, an Asian male certainly can't have a White wife who loves him enough to stay loyal, not when there's a White male out there to tempt her. But wait, there's more. Not only did she cheat with the guy, so does her husband. That's right. The rare Asian male married to a White female is, himself, LGBTQ.

What is the problem Law and Order has with Asians, especially straight Asian males? How can the franchise have been on for 30 years and still not had one as regular?

This episode was just a mess. Seriously, it's time to just end this show. For all the performative wokeness, it's just a travesty. Dicky Wolf, do you have any Asian American writers? It's Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage month, for goodness sakes, and this is how you celebrate this abused group? For shame, Dicky Wolf, for shame.
3 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed