This one did little for me when I was a kid. With morals like tolerance, loving people for who they are, multiculturalism, forgiveness, love, and friendship, it wasn't as glamorous as the Arabian design and neat little love story in Aladdin with the very funny Robin Williams as Genie. The visuals were very pretty though, the enormous and detailed stone façades and bright festival clothing of the gypsy people.
Fast forward to an adult seeing this. What brought me back was that scene where the bad guy was gazing into the fire, dishevelled, struggling while the fire and smoke danced for him. And I'm not the only one.
Judge Claude Frollo, a pious, cruel and ruthless man, has strongly sexual feelings for a female character in a Disney film, Esmeralda, and they play this out on screen. They also show him sniffing her hair. Not only that, they have him barricade a family into a house before setting it on fire to find her (not surprising, he implied he was intent on committing genocide and seemed quite at ease in the dungeons of the castle) and tries to have the Captain of the Guard killed and leave him to have a slow drowning death because he refused to do it himself. Then he captures her and puts it to her - either she be with him (presumably as a mistress - a man of his stature unmarried would be very unusual in those days, and she's a gypsy) or she dies. Esmeralda for her part does a dance that seemed to borrow modern elements from questionable places, and while Frollo's behaviour is never to be condoned, he would likely never have seen such a display.
Of course, none of these things are particularly self-evident to children who watch this film and for me as a child it went over my head.
But really, why this is important is it pushed boundaries Disney probably thought it never would. It is an adaptation of a far gory and less neat source. It creates a villain of which Disney has created few equals to in terms of his depravity. And a connection between two characters that has gone far beyond in adult nature what was done previously and since.
Jasmine in Aladdin tried to sexually seduce Jafar to protect Aladdin. This isn't quite as bigger plot element though and doesn't have a musical number. It's what the internet has called "Fresme" (Frollo/Esmeralda), and Disney knows it's a thing. Search for "11- 08-2012 - Esmeralda and Frollo - Disneyland Paris" and see cast members in Euro Disney play it up, with Esmeralda's supposed love Phoebus no-where to be seen and Frollo chasing Esmeralda around and asking her to dance. Dig further and there's pictures of him clutching her, stroking her face, hugging her. Cast Member Esmeralda, by contrast, looks happy while all this is going on. And while nobody would ever expect the Parks Jasmine to dance in a red outfit for Jafar, it's not quite the same for Hunchback. A majority of the fan activity on the internet about this movie is directed at Fresme.
This movie has become one of my favourites for the risks it took and the elements it created. It's not very charming unlike a Snow White or a Sleeping Beauty (sans the architecture which is fantastic), and the ending is unsatisfying (from my perspective) but it's like eating a whole tub of icecream in one sitting - wicked but so good.
0 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends