The Greatest Hits (2024) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
28 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
song sung blue
ferguson-63 April 2024
Greetings again from the darkness. If you are one for whom hearing a particular song, no matter how many times over however many years, brings back vivid memories of a person close to you or a memorable event, then you will likely relate to Harriet, the lead character in this film from writer-director Ned Benson (THE DISAPPEARANCE OF ELEANOR RIGBY, 2014). Additionally, if you have tragically lost someone special to you and find yourself cloaked in unshakeable grief, then you will also likely find common ground with Harriet.

Harriet (Lucy Boynton, so good in SING STREET, 2016) wears noise-cancelling headphones whenever she is in public. She is so concerned with controlling the songs she hears, that she now works in a library for the serenity that silence brings. These steps are for a good reason ... they protect her from instantaneously being transported back in time to a specific moment with her beloved boyfriend Max (David Corenswet, "Hollywood" mini-series, and he's the new Superman). For Harriet, these aren't merely flashbacks or memories - she is physically transported back in time when she hears a song. Rather than HOT TUB TIME MACHINE, she's living "Hi-Fidelity Time Machine". Her trip only lasts as long as the song is playing, yet she has no control. Once back in real time, she is viewed as having had a seizure. It's frightening stuff for her. However, instead of being concerned about her health, she is intent on finding the song that takes her back to the moment she can change the past and prevent the accident that cost Max his life.

Harriet's BFF Morris (Austin Crute, BOOKSMART, 2019), a local DJ, has been very supportive of her grief, but it's been two years since Max died, and Morris wants his friend to move on with life. Hope springs when Harriet meets David (a terrific Justin Min, "Beef") at a grief counseling group event. The two are understandable tentative around each other, yet it's obvious David is a good dude with the necessary patience to allow her to work through her grief. Harriet's case of déjà vu with David comes full circle, and adds a nice touch to the delicate situation they find themselves locked in.

Wanting to change the past is something we have all thought of at one time or another, yet the physical transformations that Harriet experiences feel like something beyond science fiction, and bordering on psychological torture. Filmmaker Benson has delivered a film that is simultaneously relatable, while also landing pretty far outside the box. There is a throwback feeling here, despite the characters feeling very much of this day. As you might expect, the soundtrack is quite varied with some deep cuts ... with Roxy Music being a key. Although there may not be any big surprises in how the story unfolds, the characters are so relatable, and it's so well acted, that we find ourselves pulling for each of them to have a happy ending.

Opens in theaters beginning April 5, 2024.
23 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
intriguing elevator pitch
SnoopyStyle16 April 2024
Everybody has songs which bring them back to specific times in their lives. For Harriet Gibbons (Lucy Boynton), it happens literally as she travels back in time. She is trying to save her boyfriend Max Enders (David Corenswet) from a deadly crash. She meets David Park (Justin H. Min) at her self-help group.

This has an intriguing elevator pitch from filmmaker Ned Benson. He has a few good ideas in this movie, but the premise needs more work. There are basic problems stemming from the concept. First, she needs to keep going back to the death moment. It only makes sense. It also doesn't help that Max is forced by the story to dismiss her at every turn. It makes him look bad as a boyfriend. The whole movie gets dragged down by many minor issues.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
intresting idea but a complete rip off of the film press play
piraterider14 April 2024
Its a intresting concept of travling through time due to certain music but this film does not deliver if you like the concept please watch press play 2022 this has tried coping the same storyline near enough with a few differances.

And as always the only 10/10 is a new account probably family members again even the 9/10 seems a bit suspect been a member 6 years and only ever reviewed this film.

Worth a watch if bored

Young Harriet discovers that art imitates life when she discovers that certain songs can literally transport her back in time. But as she relives the past through the romantic memories of her old boyfriend, her time travel collides with a new romantic adventure in her present. And so, on her journey through the hypnotic connection between music and memory, Harriet wonders if, even if she could change the past, she should.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amusing tale of love, loss, and time travel.
DarkVulcan2923 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Harriet ( Lucy Boynton ) a woman who is still grieving over the loss of her boyfriend Max ( David Corenswet ), was killed two years ago in a car accident, still having trouble coping, but meets a nice guy named David (Justin H. Min ), and slowly starts to come out of her shell. But soon something else starts to come over on Harriet, she discovers every time she listens to a certain song, it suddenly brings her back to a certain in her life, also with Max. So will Lucy move forward or change the past?

An amusing idea, that unfortunately doesn't do much with it. And David Corenswet has Max, really is just kind of there, I didn't feel we got know his character well enough, and I didn't see myself rooting for him and Boynton. Now Lucy Boynton really was great here as a grieving woman, you really feel for her and want her to be happy, and she and Justin Min had better chemistry, I found myself rooting for them more.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a deliberately vague movie?
A_Different_Drummer13 April 2024
And, to overuse a delicious quote from SEINFELD, not that there is anything wrong with that. The most interesting thing about this quite adequate film is the odd way reviewers approach it. It is as if no two pundits can agree on what they just saw? Some see a time travel film along the lines of THE TIME TRAVELOR's WIFE. Some see a deconstruction of the role of music in modern society. Some simply see a useful vehicle to move along the career of the always photogenic Boynton (who, for example, is all most of us can recall from the otherwise tedious IPCRESS FILE). Some even suggest that the film's auteur created this ambiguity deliberately to hold the attention. Which is, after all, the primary purpose of any film. Entertainment. Holding one's gaze. This reviewer, like Boynton's own character, sees all the possibilities at once, and each has merit.. But, unlike that character, will not attempt to change or alter any of them. ((Designated "IMDb Top Reviewer." Please check out my list "167+ Nearly-Perfect Movies (with the occasional Anime or TV miniseries) you can/should see again and again (1932 to the present))
10 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Music is Life!!
KTnarnia14 April 2024
This film was so well pieced together from start to finish. From the tiny details like the timeless timepiece on her wrist to the editing with the memory flashes. The acting was so much more realistic than typical movies these days. The dialogue felt natural and not forced or scripted. And the storytelling itself was just excellent! I was so impressed with this film. I was in a similar scenario as her and I have certainly been transported by music when it comes to certain songs tied to certain memories. For me, this film was like a daydream fantasy of mine that I'd give anything to be able to experience in real life. Absolutely fantastic from start to finish. 10/10.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The "ok-est" hits
MovieswDan3 May 2024
The other night my wife and I watched The Greatest Hits now streaming on Hulu. The movie stars Lucy Boynton and Justin H. Min and is written and directed by Ned Benson. The Greatest Hits follows Harriet (Boynton) as she tries to lead a normal life after the tragic death of her boyfriend. Getting over him proves to be more difficult than normal because every time Harriet hears a song that reminds her of him, she is sucked back in time until the song ends. As you can imagine, this affliction not only makes it difficult for her to get over him, but it also complicates her everyday life, including dating her new love interest David (Min).

This movie had all the makings of a cute rom com that really hits you in the feels. Unfortunately, it fell short of this goal. My overall rating for this movie is a 6.5/10 meaning that, although I did not think that this was a particularly bad movie, I also won't go as far as saying that it was good. This was a perfectly ok and forgettable movie that I will most likely never think about again after I finish writing this blog. To me, the movie did not do as good of a job of relaying the message that it wanted to convey. It seemed that it was showing us the pain of moving on and how hard it is to do that, but the execution was just lacking. The acting felt hallow and I found myself not being able to get immersed into the story. All in all, if you have something better to watch on your movie night, maybe skip The Greatest Hits.

Thanks for reading and please comment below your thoughts or if you have any suggestions on reviews you would like to see.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
couldn't finish this one
simonmattera14 April 2024
We all can agree that music has the power to bring us back to certain moments. Its attached to specific memories. So this story had potential that wasn't used at all. I can't speak for the full movie cause i stopped watching after an hour of boredom. In that hour i hardly got to know anything about this girl besides her BF died and she revisits some moments with the help of songs. But neither the soundtrack is strong in this movie (its called the greatest hits), but i miss good music here. Also the moments she revisits are dull and boring. Guess she had a very boring relationship with a guy which also stays very one dimensional during the movie and serves almost no purpose. I did not connect with those characters, nor the story, nor the vibe, nor anything. Its a complete missfire from someone who doesn't know how to make a decent movie.
18 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
PRE REVIEW! I had not seen this movie before writing the first part, but now I have.
icelandknight16 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I had NOT YET seen this movie when I wrote this review, and you may think this CRAZY, but... Just the IMDB DESCRIPTION is something I have been trying to do!!! For years!!! ??? So I was in SHOCK seeing there is a FILM based around what I have been trying to DO... That means someone else ALSO had thought about it, as a possibility! What a... "surprise". (understatement) -- but yes... I put on songs that I KNOW I listened to in my room, in Africa... and lie down, hoping that when I open my eyes... I will be BACK there... (I am in Iceland, now) So, I am VERY interested in seeing this film! :-O -- Yes, yes... I know... Its "fantasy"... and "make bellieve"... etc. BUT there are just SO MANY THINGS I would CHANGE, if I could pop back to Africa. To TELL myself what to do, and what NOT to do. That would have helped. -- I will check out the fim as soon as I can... and add an "EDIT" to this "PRE-REVIEW". (This might even be an IMDB "first".)

EDIT: wow... Its NOT like I imagined... and now I don't want to spoil it for anyone, but... In MY case, I was hoping I would just GO BACK and replace myself, in Africa, and a new life would start from there... changing stuff. (or I would see myself and afvise). They took a kind of "flashback" method. I just wanted to go back and live it, correcting mistakes... -- Ok, she does that too, in a way. Sometimes it felt a BIT on the "soppy sentimental" side... but it is a LOVE story!?! How can there NOT be "soppy" stuff... but it was all "tastefully" done, and that kinda saved it. I was more worried about the guy leaving his classic car OPEN... On the STREET... downtown... at NIGHT! We KNOW what riffraff crawl out of their dark holes, to do mischief. That KINDA got me "concerned". She also called "Max"... "David"... in the shop... I found it werid she didn't then say "DAVID" TO DAVID, when he walked right by her... ??? - I would have... Anyway. -- I am NOT going to lie, that there were no "soft eye" moments, for an audience member (me) on the journey though this film... ♥ ... and the MUSIC!!! OMG! So many GREAT covers... Cure... and I have always been a "Roxy" fan. You will know what I mean, if you see the film. -- However: To stay true to my rating system, I cannot give this more than a 7... but easily 7.6 * It was great. I liked it. Also the camera, absolutely STEADY, following the topless classic car, through the Los Angeles hills... Where I have ridden my motorcycle before. Beautiful. ♥ I regret nothing about seeing this film, and, in my opinion, the end WILL blow you away. ♥ Exquisite. I better stop, its making its way to an 8 !!! *phew* The MUSIC used in the film for memorable moments, took me back to the film "only lovers left alive" title/tt1714915/ although in a somewhat different way. -- I have now watched "Press Play"... another romantic time travelling film, and TO ME, the first part of that movie seemed "RUSHED"... When the lovebirds meet, its very clear they have no "chemistry", then they are rushed together, unconvincingly. In "Greatedt Hits" its a slower, more believable relationship that develops. Of the two, I find THIS movie better. I'd watch THIS again, not the other one. (I have no idea which came first, I'd have to check.)
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A lost opportunity to make a great film.
vgonis200219 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Films that have records and romance seem to be made more frequently that 15 years ago. It must be the so called return of the records on vinyl, because romance was in existence before 1949 and also during the low point of vinyl sales between the mid nineties and late 00's. High Fidelity was deemed the tombstone, the last movie of the dying medium, that records and romance came hand in hand, but since there is a comeback of the medium, it could as well be the springboard for everything that followed.

So here are the pros for this movie: the main idea is clever, there is romance, there is a very sweet and tender performance by Lucy Boynton, there is nice photography and nice set ups of listening rooms, record shop, library, clubs, etc. The music is good enough to carry some of the weight of the movie.

The things that hold back this movie are the awkward dialogues, that do not convey the mixed feelings they were supposed to deliver, and feel a bit iffy. The dialogues are also responsible for the weird pacing, which feels either too slow, giving the same information in many ways, or too fast, making leaps in the relation that feel un-natural. The new developing romance changes gears all too often, when it started way too fast without any justification, or without giving efficient information to back it up. Then the ensuing conversations trying to remedy a situation / relationship that hasn't really begun, feels way too much and not justified, a bit forced, too. I don't know if it is a faulty script or bad editing, but there is something wrong there.

And then I found it out while watching the film: a nice proof for her time travel, to anyone that asks, would be to name a specific public place and hide/bury an item there that would be found in the future, the second time they search. I knew this would be the solution, because it was the only reason he would be so negative to her experience, when he seemed so loving otherwise. It was carrying the plot in a most obvious way, shaking the balance all the while.

The cast couldn't carry the weight of the uneven script, and the open but hasty ending tries to smooth the corners and solve the time travel paradoxes, but actually hardly saves the day and ties loose ends. And her sacrifice rang so many familiarity bells, but I couldn't put my finger on it. It will eventually come to me and probably you!

Edit: just came to me what movie concept it reminded me of, time travel and sacrifice at the end: The butterfly effect. Let me know if it reminds you of the same!
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An Emotional Comedy, Drama, And Fantasy Film That Highlights The Impact Of Music
rannynm10 April 2024
The Greatest Hits is an emotional comedy, drama, and fantasy film that highlights the impact of music. The cute yet sentimental storyline is unique, and I especially love how this film uses music as a metaphor to depict grief, and the stages people go through processing it.

The film introduces Harriet (Lucy Boynton) who loses her boyfriend in a car accident. The tragedy leaves Harriet with trauma and also the ability to go back in time. When she hears a song that's connected with a memory, the ability to time travel is triggered, and Harriet goes back to that time. Harriet tries to bring Max back, and faces many life-challenge obstacles that don't allow her to recover from his death. Two years later, Harriet remembers the accident like it happened yesterday-she visits a support group where she meets David (Justin H. Min). And so Harriet must "face the music" and make some very tough decisions.

This film is authentic, heartbreaking, and very relatable. I love the soundtrack and connected with it so much as I constantly listen to music, and I love how music symbolizes different stages of life. Throughout the film, Harriet is desperately looking for ways to bring Max back. While this makes Harriet relatable, I also found this to be the film's biggest flaw. That being said I did find the plot to be very cute and romantic. The story is about overcoming grief, and I like how the film represents what that means to Harriet. However, the acting and script aren't as strong as I wished. Lucy Boynton does deliver a very good performance as she shows how grief can harshly impact one's life. And I liked Austin Crute's performance as Harriet's best friend-their chemistry is refreshing as he supports Harriet through her grieving process. Finally, I enjoy the aesthetic of this film-the warm cinematography is pleasing to the eye.

The message of this film is that sometimes we need to let go of the past to move forward with the present.

I give The Greatest Hits 4 out of 5 stars and recommend it for ages 12 to 18, plus adults. By Zoe C., KIDS FIRST!
18 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
CAN'T PLAY THE PERFECT MELODY
saolivaresm13 April 2024
Directed by Ned Benson and starring Lucy Boynton, David Corenswet and Justin H. Min.

Synopsis

Young Harriet discovers that art imitates life when she discovers that certain songs can literally transport her back in time. But as she relives the past through the romantic memories of her old boyfriend, her time travel collides with a new romantic adventure in her present. And so, on her journey through the hypnotic connection between music and memory, Harriet wonders if, even if she could change the past, she should.

The new romantic drama that Fox Searchlight brings us has interesting things that make you stay hooked on its story and at the same time it also has other moments where everything that makes the film not completely complete does not end up meshing. A love story about destiny and being connected that is mixed with science fiction overtones that allow the film to have various angles to engage you as a viewer, although that mix does not end up being completely well achieved.

It's not that it is a bad film, on the contrary, it is quite pleasant and can be seen without major difficulties, but its defects are felt in the shallowness of its characters, which prevents us from connecting in a unique way with its protagonists. . The interpretations of Lucy Boynton, David Corenswet and Justin H. Min are correct and do their best to give life to their characters who unfortunately lack a bit of deeper personality, it is a trio of characters that superficially fulfills, but does not satisfy to give more consistency to the story, even if there is chemistry between everyone.

A direction in line with what his script proposes, which has no greater ambitions than to give us a romantic drama to satisfy the most fans of the genre and perhaps also give a small tribute to those songs that always end up marking our lives.

A story that takes us through true love, loss, overcoming and renewal, a story that builds a journey to melancholy about the price of nostalgia. Also saying that we find an abuse of sentimentalism and little reflection, but it is also its most powerful weapon because it will make two audiences automatically connect with what those who enjoy music and those who will feel identified with those painful breakups are seeing. Loving.
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Retro Flop in Modern Wrapping
natmavila21 April 2024
Two stars might seem generous after sitting through "The Greatest Hits," a film that attempts to blend the sweet nostalgia of classic tunes with the sci-fi twist of time travel, only to miss the mark on both counts. Harriet, our protagonist, finds that certain songs can zap her back to bygone moments with an old flame, a concept that initially sounds as charming as a mixtape from a high school sweetheart. However, this cinematic journey quickly devolves into a clunky mashup of "Back to the Future" and a broken jukebox that skips the best tracks. The movie tries to tug at the heartstrings with its sentimental trips to the past, but the nostalgia is as authentic as an '80s tribute band playing from a crumpled setlist.

The real discord begins with the lack of chemistry among the cast. Harriet's adventures in time should add layers to her character, yet they flatten her into a two-dimensional figure less lively than a vinyl record's B-side. Her emotional tug-of-war between the past boyfriend and the new guy is as compelling as choosing between stale bread and slightly staler bread. The plot hopes to weave these relationships into a tapestry of learning and growth, but instead, it unravels faster than cheap headphones. Each flashback, meant to be a poignant peek into what once was, feels more like stumbling upon an awkward old Facebook photo that everyone forgot to untag.

Moreover, the film's attempt to imbue depth through music-driven time travel ends up feeling like a gimmicky afterthought. Each musical cue that sends Harriet hurtling through time is predictably on-the-nose, with song choices so literal that they'd make even a karaoke DJ cringe. By the final act, one can't help but feel that the only thing this movie transports us back to is a time when we hadn't yet watched it. "The Greatest Hits" tries to hit high notes with its innovative premise but ends up stuck in a loop of missed opportunities and flat performances. In the end, the only thing I wanted to rewind was my decision to watch it.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Retro Flop in Modern Wrapping
natmavila21 April 2024
Two stars might seem generous after sitting through "The Greatest Hits," a film that attempts to blend the sweet nostalgia of classic tunes with the sci-fi twist of time travel, only to miss the mark on both counts. Harriet, our protagonist, finds that certain songs can zap her back to bygone moments with an old flame, a concept that initially sounds as charming as a mixtape from a high school sweetheart. However, this cinematic journey quickly devolves into a clunky mashup of "Back to the Future" and a broken jukebox that skips the best tracks. The movie tries to tug at the heartstrings with its sentimental trips to the past, but the nostalgia is as authentic as an '80s tribute band playing from a crumpled setlist.

The real discord begins with the lack of chemistry among the cast. Harriet's adventures in time should add layers to her character, yet they flatten her into a two-dimensional figure less lively than a vinyl record's B-side. Her emotional tug-of-war between the past boyfriend and the new guy is as compelling as choosing between stale bread and slightly staler bread. The plot hopes to weave these relationships into a tapestry of learning and growth, but instead, it unravels faster than cheap headphones. Each flashback, meant to be a poignant peek into what once was, feels more like stumbling upon an awkward old Facebook photo that everyone forgot to untag.

Moreover, the film's attempt to imbue depth through music-driven time travel ends up feeling like a gimmicky afterthought. Each musical cue that sends Harriet hurtling through time is predictably on-the-nose, with song choices so literal that they'd make even a karaoke DJ cringe. By the final act, one can't help but feel that the only thing this movie transports us back to is a time when we hadn't yet watched it. "The Greatest Hits" tries to hit high notes with its innovative premise but ends up stuck in a loop of missed opportunities and flat performances. In the end, the only thing I wanted to rewind was my decision to watch it.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A beautiful movie for grief
mrsjennifermcfly5 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I'm not sure what the low ratings are about, I think maybe you need to have experienced grief (or are currently) to appreciate. The time travel via music is a device to show how all encompassing and overwhelming grief can be. I think we all hope that we could go back to that one moment.... David, who wants to live in the now and deal with the practical parts of losing someone, is such a perfect counterpart to Harriet, who is drowning and isolating herself in every way possible. David sees music as a positive nostalgic experience, while Harriet sees it as a way to block out the world and live in her own version of the past. In grief, you contemplate what was real, what if you forget, and whether the grief was worth the experience of knowing and living. Music, like grief, is something we all experience differently - but we all experience.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The creative spark stopped after one hour
burgerman9328 April 2024
I thought the movie would have had a bit more adventure, as time travel was the main plot device. Over time the script became dull and a lot of the music was a distractor as opposed to tying in with the story. The writers needed to smooth out the rough edges on the script and simplify the story a bit. For example, the therapist, Harriet's best friend, and David's sister were useless characters who had nothing to contribute. I did appreciate the chemistry between David and Harriet, and that both characters suffered an immeasurable amount of grief.

If you're a record collector or someone who is a sucker for romantic movies that tug at your heart strings, you might like this. From my perspective, the fun moments were infrequent and forced. Think of the movie as a Powerpoint presentation that moves so quickly, that you don't have time to take in the details.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Unwatchable
nayz-98-41892413 April 2024
Seems to start in the middle of a dream or something.

Is ultra disorienting. The sound design is bizarre. I watched very little of this , the premise sounds nothing short of amazing. The actual movie if you can call it that is extremely incoherent in every possible way. It's literally like someone filmed a dream but in the worst possible way. No context. Is billed as a romance. And if you believe romance is abstract, chaotic and meaningless than yes you will see this as a romance.

Some other random notes , movies that feature silent discos are immediately irrelevant! Not being able to hear dialogue over the score is extremely annoying! Karaoke is bad enough is real life. Cars for kids is not a song! I thought smoking in movies was a thing of the past! Does this movie have an ending or does it just stop?
7 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Romantic movie
charlotteverly13 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Anyone who has ever lost a partner will identify with the main character of the film. I loved this movie and highly recommend it to anyone who has ever loved and lost. The main characters are beautiful and skilled actors. I found the leads charismatic and they drew me in to become involved in the outcome of the premise that one can change the past. The music is good and the photography of Los Angeles is interesting. The title, in my opinion is misleading as I did not recognize many of the songs, the film is set in the present day Los Angeles with newer songs of this era. You should definately watch this film!
10 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Derivative and smothered with faux LA cool
stevelivesey-3718324 April 2024
Here's the problem. Other films have done this 'music is the centre of our relationship' schtick before and done in way better. Think, Hi-fidelity or Nick and Nora's Infinite Playlist then take away all the heart and the drama and the characters and the comedy and, well, just any interesting stuff that makes a film interesting to watch, and, boom, you have The Greatest Hits.

Then after all of that, set it in LA, have it poorly acted with everyone trying to be really rad, cool and/or laid back and go to do 'cool' LA things (silent disco, driving around in a vintage convertible in LA.....when has that ever been fun)
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Yeah, no!
MovieCriticOnline26 April 2024
I mean originally I thought it was an interesting concept, but quickly it began to follow no logic.

She was time traveling based on songs she heard? What?

Then the forced DEI cast didn't help. Stop casting actors based on some checklist HR department handed out.

And like people are actually playing vinyl everywhere? I mean, come on. And someone actually said "what in the Luther Vandross name is going on." None of these zoomers have heard of Luther.

It was shot well, and it had a nice mod to it, but I didn't buy for one second any of the characters and their relationships. The lead is best friends with a drag queen? I mean, seriously. Never happened in real life and the only reason it did happen is because of the DEI requirements.

She still went to recovery meetings after 2 years of losing her boyfriend? Again, really? Do you know ANYONE that goes to meetings after losing someone?

The direction was just poor. They tried too hard too hard to make something emotional and didn't succeed.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Pitiful Pabulum
ohnemuschi-6632320 April 2024
As I get older, I find more movies, commercials, ad nauseum using the music of my youth to send a "message." When I was a child in the late 1960's and discovered music, I attached memories to that music. Now, for example, I have to turn off a diarrhea commercial when it uses a song from the 1970's. I really want to watch a hemorrhoid commercial that uses a "Taylor Swift" song instead of a classic rock, blues or R&B song. It is intellectual laziness on the part of advertisers, Hollywood, and the entire entertainment industry. My final example of what used to be entertainment is a great movie. I re-watched "Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid" the other night. There was an obscure actor named Bob Dylan in that movie. He wrote and sang most of the soundtrack. "Knocking on Heaven's Door", to me, is the scene where Slim Pickens is dying after being shot by Billy, not some car commercial from Peugeot. I would love to be around when this generation gets to watch a commercial for heartburn to the tune of Miley Cyrus...
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Overall 8/10
jaegrayson5 May 2024
This is a great indie romantic/drama with a little bit of scifi sprinkled into the film. Not only does music play a pivotal part in this film but it does in a kind of way where everyone who loves music can relate to. The addition of wanting to save a life lost with time travel and music being the key to the time travel is quite fun but mostly made to be frightening here. Not scary movie frightening, but in a way that if it happens in the wrong places someone could get hurt. The drama in this film comes from loss, grief and moving on. Anyone who's gone through losing someone can relate to this. Wishing to be able to save someone they've lost is a sad but true feeling. It's done well here.

Music being the drive here is fun. Music can absolutely bring people back to a time and place when heard and the idea of time traveling back to pivotal points in the past through hearing songs makes this a fun and beautiful story for music fans.

The acting here was also superb. The two leads had great on screen chemistry, Corenswet not so much. The best friend was a cliché that is gettin a little old and the actor did not have chemistry with the lead. The rest of the supporting cast was good. Direction here was also great. Great shots, great locations.

Some will say this is a movie for the romantic movie crowd but it does have the strength to appeal to many viewers. Those who love romantic movies, those who love all Time Travel movies, those who love music filled movies, those who've lost someone, and those who wish they could change the past. It's a well thought out film.

Over all it's a great indie film. I only give an 8/10 cus some of the actors didn't have chemistry.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Falls way short of expectations.
chand-suhas26 April 2024
Harriet is mourning her boyfriend Max and is unable to move on. She meets David at a support group and learns he is coping losing his parents. They form a bond but Harriet is unable to pursue it further as she is constantly time travelling to the past memories with Max whenever she listens to hit songs associated with Max. Would she go back in time to save Max or would she learn to find the strength required to move on, makes up rest of the story.

This definitely had an intriguing idea and the right person to direct it considering I am kind of a Sucker for time travel stories and I immensely liked Ned Benson's all 3 versions of The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby. It just made me have expectations which this film didn't meet. The narrative isn't truly engaging and turns repetitive way too soon. The love story not working, both Harriet - Max and Harriet - David, as much as it should have, hurt the film the most. This simply lacked the magic it needed to work.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Greatest Hits
henry8-31 May 2024
Harriet (Lucy Boynton) is still mourning the death of her boyfriend Max in a car accident 2 years earlier. To complicate things when certain songs are played from their time together, Harriet goes back in time to when she was with Max when it was being played. Unable to move on, she is convinced that if the right song comes along she can save him. At the same time a new man, Justin comes into her life - will she mess this up and can she save Max.

Whilst this is a fun romantic notion and the ever excellent Boynton puts in a good performance, this isn't enough to give any spring to the story. Hence everyone goes through the film largely depressed waiting for the next time shift. It's all a bit dull and the relationships with Max particularly but also with Justin don't quite ring true. Still it comes to a satisfying conclusion after 90 minutes, shame the rest couldn't have been more interesting.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Same plot and outcome as "Press Play" (2022)
super_ale0515 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is a near-exact replica of "Press Play" (2022). I love this type of pop sci-fi movie and anything having to do with music is my jam (hence the 9 score) but I'm puzzled by the redundancy with "Press Play" without credit or reference.

Loved the songs selected for the time travel sessions, though I wonder how many American twentysomethings (Gen Z) would go to a Roxy Music concert, love The The songs, choose to sing karaoke to a 10cc song and know the lyrics, etc. Whenever there's this generational taste disconnect in movie plotlines - especially around music - you can assume the soundtrack is the Director's or Writers' favorite jams and not what characters of the demographics represented in the movie would actually listen to if they were real. I kind of lose the thread of the movie when that happens.

But! It was still enjoyable, the acting was good, the soundtrack is Gen X's delight (my generation), and I'd watching again in a heartbeat. And "Press Play", too.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed